Conservative Group’s IRS Targeting Claim Can Move Forward

Friday, May 27, 2016

May 27, 2016

By Matthew Beddingfield, Bloomberg BNA – Daily Tax Report

May 26 — A conservative organization arguing the IRS targeted its application for tax-exempt status based on its political views demonstrated that its claim of unconstitutional targeting has merit, and can continue in federal district court ( Freedom Path, Inc. v. Lerner, N.D. Tex., No. 3:14-cv-01537, 5/25/16 ).

The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas on May 25 rejected the government’s motion to dismiss Freedom Path Inc.’s First Amendment claim that the Internal Revenue Service subjected the group’s applications for tax-exempt status to higher scrutiny, flagging groups that had “conservative sounding names.”


According to Freedom Path, the government violated its First Amendment rights by subjecting its application to heightened scrutiny and unconstitutional requests for information.



Fitzwater also rejected the government’s argument that the group’s standing argument failed regarding the future curtailment of speech because it was “too speculative and amorphous to give rise to standing,” saying that Freedom Path had sufficiently pleaded future harm to establish injury.


Christopher K. Gober of Gober Group PLLC represented Freedom Path. Robert J. Witte of Strasburger & Price LLP represented Lerner. Grover Hartt III of the Department of Justice represented the government.

Link to full article here.